Chirik Lab Discovers "Transformative" Route to Chemically Recyclable Plastics
By Wendy Plump
Monday, Jan. 25, 2021
As the planet’s burden of rubber and plastic rises unabated, scientists look to the promise of closed-loop recycling to reduce trash. Researchers in the Chirik Lab have discovered a potentially game-changing new molecule – from a material known for over a century and used to make common products like tires and shoe soles – with vast implications for fulfilling that promise through depolymerization.
The Chirik lab reported in Nature Chemistry that during polymerization the molecule, named (1,n’-divinyl)oligocyclobutane, enchains in a repeating sequence of squares, a previously unrealized microstructure that enables the process to go backwards, or depolymerize, under certain conditions. In other words, it can be “zipped up” to make a new polymer; that polymer can then be unzipped back to a pristine monomer to be used again.
The molecule – casually referred to around the Chirik lab as a “polymer of squares” – could one day enable the use of plastic products many times over, unlike most of today’s plastic that can only be recycled once. If at all.
“I honestly think this work is one of the most important things to ever come out of my lab,” said Paul Chirik, the Edwards S. Sanford Professor of Chemistry, of the discovery.
Collaborator Alex Carpenter simply called it “transformative.”
The research is still at an early stage and the material’s performance attributes have yet to be thoroughly explored. But under Chirik, the lab has provided a conceptual precedent for a chemical transformation not generally thought practical for certain commodity materials.
In the past, depolymerization has been accomplished with expensive, specialized polymers and only after a multitude of steps, but never from a raw material as common as this one. The molecule was found in a material called polybutadiene, which has been known for over a hundred years and is used to make rubber and plastic products. Butadiene, its parent material, is an abundant organic compound and a major byproduct of fossil fuel development.
“To take a really common chemical that people have been studying and polymerizing for many decades and make a fundamentally new material out of it – let alone have that material have interesting innate properties – not only is that unexpected, it’s really a big step forward. You wouldn’t necessarily expect there still to be fruit on that tree,” said Carpenter, a collaborator on the research and a former staff chemist with ExxonMobil Chemical.
“The focus of this collaboration for us has been on developing new materials that benefit society by focusing on some new molecules that Paul has discovered that are pretty transformative,” Carpenter added. “Humankind is good at making butadiene. It’s very nice when you can find other useful applications for this molecule, because we have plenty of it.”
Catalysis with Iron
The Chirik lab explores sustainable chemistry by investigating the use of iron – another abundant natural material – as a catalyst to synthesize new molecules. In this particular research, the iron catalyst clicks the monomers together to make oligocyclobutane. Normally, enchainment occurs with an S-shaped structure that is often described as looking like spaghetti. But with oligocyclobutane, the monomers click together in a chain of squares.
To bring about depolymerization, oligocyclobutane is exposed to a vacuum in the presence of the iron catalyst, which reverses the process and recovers the monomer. The Chirik lab’s paper, published this week, identifies this as a rare example of closed-loop chemical recycling.
The material also has intriguing properties as characterized by Megan Mohadjer Beromi, a postdoctoral fellow in the Chirik lab, together with chemists at ExxonMobil’s polymer research center. For instance, it is telechelic, meaning the chain is functionalized on both ends. This property could enable it to be used as a building block in its own right, serving as a bridge between other molecules in a polymeric chain. In addition, it is thermally stable, meaning it can be heated to above 250-degrees C without rapid decomposition.
Finally, it exhibits high crystallinity, even at a low molecular weight of 1,000 grams per mol (g/mol). This could indicate that desirable physical properties – like crystallinity and material strength – can be achieved at lower weights than generally assumed. The polyethylene used in the average plastic shopping bag, for example, has a molecular weight of 500,000g/mol.
“One of the things we demonstrate in the paper is that you can make really tough materials out of this monomer,” said Chirik. “The energy between polymer and monomer can be close, and you can go back and forth, but that doesn’t mean the polymer has to be weak. The polymer itself is strong.
“What people tend to assume is that when you have a chemically recyclable polymer, it has to be somehow inherently weak or not durable. We’ve made something that’s really, really tough but is also chemically recyclable. We can get pure monomer back out of it. And that surprised me. That’s not optimized. But it’s there. The chemistry’s clean.”
Ditching the ethylene
The project stretches back a few years to 2017, when C. Rose Kennedy, then a postdoc in the Chirik lab, noticed a viscous liquid accumulating at the bottom of a flask during a reaction. Kennedy said she was expecting something volatile to form, so the result spurred her curiosity. Digging into the reaction, she discovered a distribution of oligomers – or nonvolatile products with a low molecular weight – that indicated polymerization had taken place.
“Knowing what we knew about the mechanism already, it was pretty clear right away how this would be possible to click them together in a different or continuous way. We immediately recognized this could be something potentially extremely valuable,” said Kennedy, now an assistant professor of chemistry at the University of Rochester.
At that early point, Kennedy was enchaining butadiene and ethylene. It was Mohadjer Beromi who later surmised that it would be possible to remove the ethylene altogether and just use neat butadiene at elevated temperatures. Mohadjer Beromi “gave” the four-carbon butadiene to the iron catalyst, and that yielded the new polymer of squares.
“We knew that the motif had the propensity to be chemically recycled,” said Mohadjer Beromi. “But I think one of the new and really interesting features of the iron catalyst is that it can do [2+2] cycloadditions between two dienes, and that’s what this reaction essentially is: it’s a cycloaddition where you’re linking two olefins together to make a square molecule over and over again.
“It’s the coolest thing I’ve ever worked on in my life.”
To further characterize oligocyclobutane and understand its performance properties, the molecule needed to be scaled and studied at a larger facility with expertise in new materials.
“How do you know what you made?” Chirik asked. “We used some of the normal tools we have here at Frick. But what really matters is the physical properties of this material, and ultimately what the chain looks like.”
For that, Chirik traveled to Baytown, Texas last year to present the lab’s findings to ExxonMobil, which decided to support the work. An integrated team of scientists from Baytown were involved in computational modeling, X-ray scattering work to validate the structure, and additional characterization studies.
The chemical industry uses a small number of building blocks to make most commodity plastic and rubber. Three such examples are ethylene, propylene, and butadiene. A major challenge of recycling these materials is that they often need to be combined and then bolstered with other additives to make plastics and rubbers: additives provide the performance properties we want – the hardness of a toothpaste cap, for example, or the lightness of a grocery bag. These “ingredients” all have to be separated again in the recycling process.
But the chemical steps involved in that separation and the input of energy required to bring this about make recycling prohibitively expensive, particularly for common consumer products. Plastic is cheap, lightweight, and convenient, but it was not designed with disposal in mind. That, said Chirik, is the main problem with it.
As a possible alternative, the Chirik research demonstrates that the butadiene polymer is almost energetically equal to the monomer, which makes it a candidate for closed-loop chemical recycling.
Chemists liken the process of producing a product from a raw material to rolling a boulder up a hill, with the peak of the hill as the transition state. From that state, you roll the boulder down the other side and end up with a product. But with most plastics, the energy and cost to roll that boulder backwards up the hill to recover its raw monomer are staggering, and thus unrealistic. So, most plastic bags and rubber products and car bumpers end up in landfills.
“The interesting thing about this reaction of hooking one unit of butadiene onto the next is that the ‘destination’ is only very slightly lower in energy than the starting material,” said Kennedy. “That’s what makes it possible to go back in the other direction.”
In the next stage of research, Chirik said his lab will focus on the enchainment, which at this point chemists have only achieved on average up to 17 units. At that chain length, the material becomes crystalline and so insoluble that it falls out of the reaction mixture.
“We have to learn what to do with that,” said Chirik. “We’re limited by its own strength. I would like to see a higher molecular weight.”
Still, researchers are excited about the prospects for oligocyclobutane, and many investigations are planned in this continuing collaboration towards chemically recyclable materials.
“The current set of materials that we have nowadays doesn’t allow us to have adequate solutions to all the problems we’re trying to solve,” said Carpenter. “The belief is that, if you do good science and you publish in peer-reviewed journals and you work with world-class scientists like Paul, then that’s going to enable our company to solve important problems in a constructive way.
“This is about understanding really cool chemistry,” he added, “and trying to do something good with it.”
Read the full paper here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41557-020-00614-w.
“Iron Catalyzed Synthesis and Chemical Recycling of Telechelic, 1,3-Enchained Oligocyclobutanes,” is co-authored by Paul Chirik and Megan Mohadjer Beromi of the Chirik Lab; C. Rose Kennedy, formerly of the Chirik Lab; Jarod Younker, ExxonMobil Chemical; Alex Carpenter, formerly of ExxonMobil Chemical; Sarah Mattler, ExxonMobil Chemical; and Joseph Throckmorton, ExxonMobil Chemical. The paper appears in the Jan. 25, 2021 issue of Nature Chemistry (DOI: 10.1038/s41557-020-00614-w).
Initial funding for this work was provided by Firmenich, and the National Institutes of Health Ruth L. Kirschstein National Research Service Award (F32 GM134610 & F32 GM126640). Funding was also provided by ExxonMobil through Princeton E-filliates Partnership.